rural communities teacher education teacher enrollment programs urban schooling

Challenges and Promising Possibilities for Reversing the Trend by Logan Rutten and Azaria Cunningham – AJE Forum

Photograph by Flickr Consumer Sint Smeding

The variety of individuals graduating from instructor education schemes (TEPs) in the United States has fallen sharply in the previous decade, and the development appears more likely to continue. The decline in individuals getting ready to show comes at a time when many faculty districts are already struggling to rent a licensed instructor for each classroom. Furthermore, instructor shortages are affecting the United States erratically, with rural and city areas the hardest hit (Strauss, 2017, 2018; Vilorio, 2016). Getting ready and hiring sufficient qualified academics is just one facet of the drawback, which is compounded by persistent considerations about low charges of instructor retention (Han & Yin, 2016). Briefly, not sufficient individuals are turning into academics and staying in the classroom in the locations where the need is biggest.

This essay begins by establishing the existence of an issue by sharing some slices of the knowledge on TEP enrollments. Next, we think about how we, as future instructor educators, could be part of the answer. We propose that revolutionary recruitment packages and partnerships between faculties and schools of instructor schooling are a promising strategy. Nevertheless, we also acknowledge that students are framing the drawback and attainable solutions from quite a lot of different views. For example, economists of schooling are considering the salaries new academics can anticipate to earn (Park & Byun, 2015). Schooling policy students and curriculum theorists alike are taken with unfavorable social development (Schneider & Ingraham, 1993) and deprofessionalizing discourses that encompass academics in this country (Strauss, 2017). Subsequently, so as to paint a richer picture of the drawback of low TEP enrollments than we will accomplish alone, we’ve invited colleagues from other fields to contribute further commentaries to the AJE Forum over the coming weeks.

How massive is the drawback?

In line with a 2018 report of the American Affiliation of Schools for Instructor Schooling entitled Schools of Schooling: A Nationwide Portrait, the ongoing decline in instructor schooling program enrollments displays a continuation of a long-term nationwide development: there are presently fewer than 100,000 undergraduate degrees in schooling being awarded yearly in comparison with almost twice that quantity in the 1970s. Some states have seen pronounced declines inside the previous couple of years alone. One example may be found in the most recent U.S. Department of Schooling (2018) stories on Title II of the Greater Schooling Act. Based on the report, in Pennsylvania alone, there was an general lower in enrollments (from 18,630 to 14,387) and completions (from 8,549 to six,375) of instructor preparation packages between 2013-2014 and 2015-2016. The info embrace declines in traditional, university-based packages of instructor preparation as well as in various certification packages. Nevertheless, the bulk of the decline in Pennsylvania enrollments (18,188 to 14,118) and completions (8,237 to six,113) occurred in conventional packages, reflecting broader national patterns.

If there were an present surplus of licensed academics throughout the nation, the decline in TEP enrollments won’t be cause for alarm. Nevertheless, as of the 2017-2018 faculty yr, every state had a shortage of academics in at the very least some licensure areas (Strauss, 2017). Arithmetic, science, world languages, and particular schooling are just some of the areas of biggest need. We must tackle these shortages and spend money on high quality instructor schooling if we would like college students to graduate from highschool prepared for no matter their futures might maintain, let alone as considerate and engaged citizens of our democracy.

“…the problem is not merely raising enrollments in TEPs but to increase the number of teachers who graduate with a certification and find long-term success in the classroom”

What can instructor educators do about the shortages?

Given the precipitous decline in TEP enrollments, we contend that institutions that prepare academics can’t afford to assume that motivated candidates will appear on their doorsteps. To ensure their very own continued existence, to say nothing of meeting the pressing societal want for qualified academics, TEPs will need to take a more lively position in recruiting potential academics.

We propose that packages and partnerships between TEPs, faculties, and communities are a strong means for instructor educators to help handle the drawback. The Kansas Future Instructor Academy (KFTA) is one instance of such a program (Lyman, Foyle, Morehead, Schwerdtfeger, & Lyman, 2017). KFTA is sponsored by the Academics School at Emporia State College and is open to all Kansas high school college students. Annually, KFTA employees contact all highschool counselors and principals in each public and personal faculties across Kansas to ask students to attend a week-long camp at Emporia State College’s campus (KFTA, 2019). Throughout the camp, attendees discover the rewarding work of educating by shadowing veteran educators and talking to them about their work. Further, they’re supported as they make high school course choices that may put together them to be successful as instructor schooling candidates (Lyman et al., 2017). Since 1989, KFTA has hosted more than 1,200 prospective academics (KFTA, 2019).

We view packages like the Kansas Future Instructor Academy as a robust step in the right course for TEPs. Taking a proactive strategy to recruitment is definitely better than waiting for college students to seek out, apply to, and enroll in TEPs on their own. Nevertheless, packages like KFTA typically have limitations that limit entry. For instance, this yr KFTA is requesting that individuals pay a $100 program charge (KFTA, 2019). While this will appear to be a modest sum for a whole week of activities, it might also present hardship for some promising prospective academics. If charge waivers can be found, this isn’t made clear on KFTA’s website. Further, the geographic location of such packages might current a problem. In the case of KFTA, the program is housed in rural Emporia, Kansas. Whereas Emporia may be an applicable setting to study educating in a rural space, it will not be as successful in attracting college students all in favour of city educating as a program in an city area. Highschool college students who commute utilizing public transportation might also have difficulties accessing a rural program like KFTA. We see these limitations as surmountable by means of the creation of networks of similar packages in city in addition to rural areas, and by means of decreasing or eliminating direct costs to students.

It isn’t sufficient, nevertheless, for instructor education schemes to draw students. In any case, the drawback shouldn’t be merely elevating enrollments in TEPs but to extend the variety of academics who graduate with a certification and find long-term success in the classroom. Because of this, TEPs must also help instructor candidates all through their enrollment and into their first years of educating. Strong packages of mentoring, reminiscent of those typically discovered both formally or informally at TEPs housed in minority-serving establishments (Petchauer & Mawhinney, 2017), are one facet of help throughout the TEP. Skilled improvement faculties, that are a singular form of mutually useful partnership between universities, faculties, and typically communities (Lyman et al., 2017), present one other avenue to help instructor schooling college students. Via extended, typically year-long subject experiences, skilled improvement faculties have proven promise for getting ready academics who consider in their own talents as educators (Latham & Vogt, 2007) and who keep in the subject (Helfeldt, Capraro, Capraro, Foster, & Carter, 2009). Such partnerships is probably not a silver bullet, however they hold substantial prospects for constructing a dedicated, highly qualified educating pressure.

We acknowledge that partnerships include a price of time, power, and cash. Nevertheless, there’s additionally a societal value incurred by faculties, communities, and students who wouldn’t have certified academics in every classroom. In our view, partnerships are one sensible answer to declining TEP enrollments. Partnerships are also a worthwhile funding yielding both measurable and immeasurable dividends.

How else may we take into consideration TEP enrollments?

In the subsequent article in this collection, Azaria Cunningham will share a narrative of her experiences as a scholar in a partnership which sought to determine city high school students dedicated to turning into academics of their house communities. Later, Hansol Woo considers the motivations of individuals getting into educating together with some of the social, economic, and labor circumstances of the educating career in the United States. It is our hope that together we will come to know the drawback of declining TEP enrollments more absolutely and generate progressive options. We invite you to hitch our conversation by commenting under, partaking us on AJE’s social media platforms, or submitting an essay of your personal.

Logan Rutten is a Ph.D. candidate in Curriculum and Supervision at Penn State College. A classicist and musician, he has taught grades Okay-12 in public, charter, and cyber faculties. Logan’s current research examines the pedagogy of instructor inquiry, preservice academics’ motivations, shared experience and instructor studying in school-university partnerships, and the democratic context for education. He earned a B.A. at Concordia School and an M.Ed. from Penn State.

Azaria Cunningham is a Ph.D. candidate in Curriculum and Instruction at Penn State College. She holds a B.A. in Built-in Arithmetic and Science and a Master’s Diploma in Greater Schooling from William Paterson University of New Jersey. Before starting her doctoral research, Azaria taught middle faculty science.


Han, J., & Yin, H. (2016). Instructor motivation: Definition, analysis improvement and implications for academics. Instructor Schooling & Improvement, three. DOI:

Helfeldt, J. P., Capraro, R. M., Capraro, M. M., Foster, E., & Carter, N. (2009). The Instructor Educator, 44(1), 1-20.

Kansas Future Instructor Academy. (2019). Retrieved from

King, J. E. (2018). Schools of schooling: A national portrait. Report of the American Affiliation of Schools for Instructor Schooling. Retrieved from

Latham, N. I., & Vogt, W. P. (2007). Do skilled improvement faculties scale back instructor attrition? Evidence from a longitudinal research of 1,000 graduates. Journal of Instructor Schooling, 52(2), 153-167.L

Lyman, L., Foyle, H. C., Morehead, M. A., Schwerdtfeger, S., & Lyman, A. L. (2017). Mentoring scholar academics and interns: Methods for partaking, relating, supporting, and challenging future educators (third ed.). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Park, H. & Byun, S. Y. (2015). Why some nations appeal to extra high-ability younger college students to educating: Cross-national comparisons of scholars’ expectation of turning into a instructor. Comparative Schooling Evaluation, 59(three), 523-549.

Petchauer, E., & Mawhinney, L. (Eds.). (2017). Instructor schooling throughout minority-serving establishments: Packages, insurance policies, and social justice. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

Schneider, A., & Ingram, H. (1993). Social development of target populations: Implications for politics and coverage. The American Political Science Evaluation, 87(2), 334-347.

Strauss, V. (2017, August 28). Instructor shortages affecting each state as 2017-2018 faculty yr begins. Washington Submit. Retrieved from

Strauss, V. (2018, Might 18). Instructor shortages are particularly acute in rural areas. Right here’s one answer in Colorado. Washington Submit. Retrieved from

United States Department of Schooling (2018). 2017 Title II Reviews. Nationwide Instructor Preparation Knowledge. Retrieved from

Vilioro, D. (2016, June). Educating for a dwelling. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Retrieved from